An archive the questions from Mark's Fall 2018 Complex Variables Course.

Classification of sets

Mark

Classify the sets below as

  • Open, closed, or neither
  • Bounded or unbounded
  • Connected or disconnected

  1. \mathbb C
  2. \mathbb R
  3. \mathbb N
  4. \{z \in \mathbb C: \text{Re}(z)>0\}
  5. \{z \in \mathbb C: \text{Re}(z)>0 \text{ and } \text{Im}(z)\geq0\}
  6. \{z \in \mathbb C: z\overline{z}\leq4\}
Great_Big

Note: for the purpose of classification, we’ll consider \mathbb{C} to be the “ambient space” of all these sets, meaning that when we consider each set, we’ll think of it being “surrounded” by \mathbb{C}, rather than being isolated.

\mathbb{C}
For sure \mathbb{C} is open since for any point we can find an open disc centered on the point that is a subset of \mathbb{C}. Also, \mathbb{C} doesn’t have any boundary points, so the (empty) set of boundary points is contained within \mathbb{C}, which implies \mathbb{C} is closed.
We surely can’t contain all of \mathbb{C} is an open disc, so \mathbb{C} is unbounded.
Intuitively, \mathbb{C} is connected since we can’t find any two non-empty disjoint sets whose union is \mathbb{C}

\mathbb{R}
If \mathbb{C} is the ambient space of \mathbb{R}, then \mathbb{R} is closed since all of the boundary points of \mathbb{R} are elements of \mathbb{R}.
We can’t contain \mathbb{R} in an open disc, so it is unbounded.
\mathbb{R} is connected since we can’t find any two non-empty disjoint sets whose union is \mathbb{R}.

\mathbb{N}
If \mathbb{C} is the ambient space of \mathbb{N}, then \mathbb{N} is closed since all of the boundary points of \mathbb{N} are elements of \mathbb{N} (or better yet, because \mathbb{N}^\complement is open).
\mathbb{N} is unbounded since we can’t contain it in an open disc.
\mathbb{N} is disconnected since the union of the even naturals and the odd naturals forms the naturals.

\{z\in\mathbb{C}: \text{Re}(z)>0\}
This guy is open, unbounded, and connected.

\{z\in\mathbb{C}: \text{Re}(z)>0 \text{ and Im}(z) \geq 0 \}
This set is not open since those elements of the set with imaginary components equal to 0 are not interior points. This set is not closed since those complex numbers with real components equal to 0 are boundary points of the set but not members of the set.
This set is unbounded.
This set is connected.

\{z\in\mathbb{C}: z\bar{z}\leq 4\}=\{z\in\mathbb{C}: |z|^2\leq 4\}
This set is closed since its boundary points, \partial(\{z\in\mathbb{C}: z\bar{z}\leq 4\}) = \{z\in \mathbb{C}: |z| = 2\}, are all members of the set.
This set is bounded since the disc of radius 3 centered at 0 contains the set.
Lastly, this set is connected.

Mark

I agree. Can you identify the set precisely?

jgomez28314

Is this the set?

(based on Filliam_wisher and Dr. McClure’s work)

\{ \exists U | U \supset \mathbb{Z} : z\overline z \leq 4\} \supset \{z \in \mathbb{C} | \hspace{2mm} |z|^{2} \leq 4\}

where,

|z|^2

refers to the order of z and its accumulation point at

\delta(\{z\in \mathbb{C}:z\overline z \leq 4 \} ) \subseteq \{z \in \mathbb{C} | \hspace{2mm} |z| = 2\}
(\hspace{1mm} \forall \hspace{1mm} V | z\in \mathbb{C} : |z| = 2)(\hspace{1mm} \exists \hspace{1mm} U|U \supset Z \in \mathbb{C} : z\overline z \subseteq 4 )

where,

(\forall A\in \mathbb{C} | \hspace{2mm} |z|^2 \leq 4)(\hspace{1mm}\exists \hspace{1mm} B \in \delta A | \hspace{2mm} A \cup B \supset U)